Imagine this. You are just an ordinary guy, like a lot of others. Then one of your older brothers heads out West, and winds up working in Hollywood. It's interesting, yet what dos that have to do with you? Time passes, and nothing extraordinary happens until you receive a letter from your big bro asking if you'd like to visit him in Tinseltown? You're the kind of fellow who is a natural round peg in a field of square holes. It's hard to get a sense for what you want to do with your life, and there are no prospects on your home turf. So, why not? You wire your brother and tell him you'll be right over.
You arrive on the West Coast to discover that Big Brother has made something of a name and reputation for himself. He's smart enough to see that baby bro doesn't know what to do with himself, so as a humiliating form of pity, he takes you under his wing. You help him out on minor stuff, mainly lighting and handling the film cameras. One day you run across
Mr. Carl Laemmle. For what ever reason, this man you've hardly met before thinks he "sees something" in you. The guy's delusional, there's no doubt about that, but he's the boss, so you humor him and go along with whatever he wants. Mr. Laemmle does the irresponsible thing by placing you in a director's chair, and gives you a film to make.
The job is okay, at first. You spend most of your time trying to get a ship of fools to follow orders. The funny thing is you discover a knack for always finding where you want the camera to be. You also have a way of making the actors hit whatever mark the script says they should. One day you wake up to discover you've made name for yourself. This is both wonderful and horrifying at the same time, with the latter tending to dominate. For one thing while it's great to have a secure future, you find that perhaps you don't really fit in any better in Hollywood than you did in your old hometown in Maine. You grow famous by telling stories of heroes and the history of the American West. You even have the knack for discovering talent in the form of a big lug with the ridiculous name of Marion Morrison. After some deliberation, the kid (who prefers the nickname of "Duke") settles on John Wayne as a title.
Together you and the Duke manage to give an identity to what some will go on to call Hollywood's Golden Age. None of it makes you comfortable and it never gets any easier. You care about you're wife and kids and yet you make a series of unfortunate discoveries. The worst of it is that you focus on heroism in your film's so much because you are either a coward, or else you just can't help thinking that you're one. This makes you unhappy enough to have a fair temper. You lose it because you're unhappy and you're unhappy because you lose it. You wonder if there's a way it could ever have been different? Who knows. Perhaps you're own cowardice is the reason you are able to depict heroism and its darker shades, so well Still, you can't deny the accomplishments of John Ford, even if he never existed. "This is the west, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend".
This at least is what happened with the life of John "Jack" Feeney. In a career that lasted from the Silent Era to the birth of New Wave Cinema, he managed a creative arc that is both iconic and, sadly, almost forgotten in a post-millennial age. Ford cemented his identity with
Stagecoach, released in 1939. It was also John Wayne's breakout role, and it helped cement the both of them as artists who specialized in the Western genre. Their subject matter would be a gritty merciless examination of the history of the frontier. That's the popular legacy of Ford, and while it is true to an extent, it is still just one facet of much wider story. The irony is what do you do when even the truth sells you a bit short?
In addition to the films that made his reputation, there was also an intermediate period where Ford tried his hand at a number projects in different genres. Most of these were were best described as social realist dramas, although he did branch a bit further on occasions. When that happened, you could get an adaptation of Steinbeck or
Eugene O'Neil. He made
a jungle adventure story with Clarke Gable if you can believe it. He even did
a slice of life crime drama at one point. In Hollywood anything can happen. I mean anything.
Scholars and critics tend to view 1939 to perhaps 1946 as the director's peak years. Those were the years Ford directed
Young Mr. Lincoln,
How Green was my Valley, and
My Darling Clementine. All of these films are of value. Each of them deserves a post of their own. To start with, however, I'd like to take a look at the one film that in many ways is the last one anyone could expect of John Ford. The irony is that while the film can be described as "out of character" for its director, it also contains a lot of the themes that reappear in his other films. In order to make sense of all this however, we have to get to know the star of the picture.